With 12 full days left until the 2024 U.S. presidential election,Scarlett Fay Archives there are still concerns about if Meta can properly moderate political content on its platforms.
Two months ago, a Facebook user put the faces of presidential candidate Vice President Kamala Harris and her running mate Minnesota Governor Tim Walz on top of Jim Carrey and Jeff Daniels' characters in the Dumb and Dumber movie poster. The poster features Carrey and Daniels' characters grabbing each other's nipples — you know the one. The user then captioned it with the emojis "🤷♂️🖕🖕."
SEE ALSO: X hiring content moderators for a new 'Trust and Safety' center in AustinMeta removed the post because it went against the platform's Bullying and Harassment Community Standard, specifically because that standard doesn't allow "derogatory sexualized photoshop or drawings." The user appealed Meta's decision, which moved the decision up to Meta's Oversight Board. After that, Meta "determined its removal was incorrect, restoring the post to Facebook."
Meta's oversight board is a group with more than 20 members, including academics, policymakers, and journalists, and this group makes content moderation decisions on Facebook and Instagram. The board wrote that Meta's handling of this post gives them "serious concerns" about Meta's ability to moderate political content on its platforms.
"This post is nothing more than a commonplace satirical image of prominent politicians and is instantly recognizable as such," the board wrote. It continued:
In the context of elections, the Board has previously recommended that Meta should develop a framework for evaluating its election integrity efforts in order to provide the company with relevant data to improve its content moderation system as a whole and decide how to best employ its resources in electoral contexts.
It then referred to a previous case surrounding a general in Brazil who, amid that country's 2022 elections, called on activists to "hit the streets" — a remark tied to protesters storming Brazil's National Congress and Supreme Court. The board at the time made the opposite determination: that Meta failed by notremoving the general's remarks in time to avoid adding to a volatile situation. The board, apparently, wants to see progress on the creation of a system of rules that would cover that past false negative, as well as this false positive.
Its statement continued:
Meta has reported progress on implementing this recommendation. Nonetheless, the company’s failure to recognize the nature of this post and treat it accordingly raises serious concerns about the systems and resources Meta has in place to effectively make content determinations in such electoral contexts.
The board wrote that it sees an "overenforcement of Meta’s Bullying and Harassment policy with respect to satire and political speech in the form of a non-sexualized derogatory depiction of political figures." It says this overenforcement could "lead to the excessive removal of political speech and undermine the ability to criticize government officials and political candidates, including in a sarcastic manner."
Topics Social Media
Stephanie Danler on “Sweetbitter” & Reducing Fiction to EssentialsStaff Picks: Prince, Mary Ruefle, and Mary ShelleyNew York ValuesThe Conspiratorial Saleslady: “Life’s Short; We Need Beautiful Things”The Secret’s Out: We’re BORING AS FUCKHaving Trouble Sleeping? Read This Extremely Boring Writing…Karl Ove Knausgaard, PublisherR. Crumb Is Still Weird (Thank God!)Cancel Your Plans—the Guggenheim Has a Solid Gold ToiletRemembering Jenny Diski (1947–2016)Glen Baxter Week, Day Four: Library Police, Shocking Scouts“Own It!”: The Most Grating Phrase of the MomentWhat the World Needs Now Is More Geodesic DomesTitle Fights: Who Gets to Name an Author’s Book?The Conspiratorial Saleslady: “Life’s Short; We Need Beautiful Things”Branded Man: The Long Tradition of Outlaw PoetsThe Single Girl’s Guide to ArtJohn Betjeman Reads “The Licorice Fields at Pontefract”The Conspiratorial Saleslady: “Life’s Short; We Need Beautiful Things”Stephanie Danler on “Sweetbitter” & Reducing Fiction to Essentials Wrangler captures massive crocodile '10 times' the size of him Google fires engineer behind sexist 'manifesto,' alt Amazon and the Dog Whisperer are bringing audiobooks to your posh pup Disney Channel features interracial lesbian couple and other networks should catch up already Everyone else give up and let this guy show you how to Tinder 5 active duty transgender service members are suing Donald Trump over military ban The deepfake apocalypse never came. But cheapfakes are everywhere. iPhone 12 owners can now download iOS updates over 5G, if they turn this option on Florida man discovers huge snake has been living in his attic for years Google repeatedly shuts down questions on sexism—and that's a problem Americans asked Google a bunch of unintentionally funny election questions this week How to stream the final presidential debate Robert Pattinson's quest for a NYC hot dog is pure art See Hummer EV do its CrabWalk move on video 15 anthems of self Quibi, the buzzy streamer with tons of star power, is shutting down Why Trump's fiery language about North Korea sounds eerily familiar Trump trolled with Putin projection and 'Russian soldiers' at his SoHo building Why GMC's new electric Hummer is a bigger deal than Tesla's Cybertruck 5G drains iPhone 12's battery 20 percent faster, test shows
1.4026s , 10138.1796875 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Scarlett Fay Archives】,Miracle Information Network