Perhaps you've been here this holiday season: A family member shares a political belief that is eroticized synonymentirely the opposite of your own, and suddenly your blood is boiling. You either bite your tongue, and quietly fill with rage, or fire back with an impassioned rebuttal.
Neuroscientists say they now can track how this common experience unfolds in the brain.
When our political beliefs are challenged, our brains light up in areas that govern personal identity and emotional responses to threats, according to a study published Dec. 23 in the Nature journal Scientific Reports.
"Political beliefs are like religious beliefs, in the respect that both are part of who you are and important for the social circle to which you belong," Jonas Kaplan, the study's lead author and a psychological professor at the University of Southern California (USC)'s Brain and Creativity Institute, said in a news release.
"To consider an alternative view, you would have to consider an alternative version of yourself," Kaplan said.
The study offers a fresh perspective on how people respond to conflicting ideas -- be they political opinions or the dubious contents of fake news stories -- and could help us figure out how to have more constructive conversations during these divisive times, said Sarah Gimbel, a co-author and research scientist at the Brain and Creativity Institute.
"Understanding when and why people are likely to change their minds is an urgent objective," she said in a statement.
For the study, the neuroscientists recruited 40 self-declared liberals.
The team then used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to measure brain activity by detecting changes in blood flow. Sam Harris, a neuroscientist at Project Reason in Los Angeles, also worked on the study.
Researchers wanted to determine which brain networks would respond when someone's firmly held beliefs are challenged. So they compared whether and how much participants changed their minds on political and non-political issues when provided counter-evidence.
During their sessions, participants were presented with eight political statements that they said they agreed with, such as, "The laws regulating gun ownership in the United States should be made more restrictive," or that the U.S. should reduce funding for the military.
Participants were then shown five counter claims challenging each statement. Next, they rated the strength of their belief in the original statement on a scale of 1-7.
The neuroscientists studied participants' brain scans during these exercises to figure out which areas were the most engaged.
Researchers found that the brain's amygdala and insular cortex were more active in people who were most resistant to changing their beliefs. Both brain areas are important for emotion and decision-making and are associated with fear, anxiety, emotional responses and the perception of threat.
Participants' default mode networks -- a system in the brain -- also saw a spike in activity when people's political beliefs were challenged.
"These areas of the brain have been linked to thinking about who we are, and with the kind of rumination or deep thinking that takes us away from the here and now," Kaplan said.
But while people wouldn't budge on political topics like abortion or same-sex marriage, participants tended to cling less tightly to their beliefs on non-political topics.
For instance, participants' beliefs weakened by one or two points when they were shown counter evidence on statements such as whether "Thomas Edison invented the light bulb" or "Albert Einstein was the greatest physicist of the 20th century."
Brain activity in the amygdala and insular cortex was also less active when people were more willing to change their minds, the researchers found.
"I was surprised that people would doubt that Einstein was a great physicist, but this study showed that there are certain realms where we retain flexibility in our beliefs," Kaplan said.
Topics Politics
Wordle today: The answer and hints for January 24, 2025Samsung Unpacked live stream: See the Galaxy S25 announcement liveBest Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra case deal: Save $15 on silicone case at Best BuyNYT Connections Sports Edition hints and answers for January 24: Tips to solve Connections #123Best streaming deal: Get a year of Starz for just $36Best Amazon deals of the day: Samsung Galaxy Tab S10+, 55Wordle today: The answer and hints for January 24, 2025Best Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra case deal: Save $15 on silicone case at Best Buy'Assassin's Creed Shadows' has a little something for everybodySamsung Galaxy S25 preorder bonus: Get a free gift card worth up to $200 from Amazon, Best BuyBest Amazon deals of the day: Samsung Galaxy Tab S10+, 55Best headphones deal: Save $30 on JLab JBuds Lux ANCInstant Pot Duo Plus deal: $69.99 at AmazonGameStop buy one, get one 50% off sale: How to shop'Severance' Season 2 opening credits, explainedInstant Pot Duo Plus deal: $69.99 at AmazonSouthern dogs experiencing snow for the first time is super heartwarmingBest Dyson Supersonic Hair Dryer deal: Save $210 when you buy refurbished at WalmartBest Amazon deal: Get a free $100 Amazon gift card when you preStuff Your Kindle Day Jan. 23: Free historical cozy mystery e William Pope.L and the Black Flâneur Listen to a 2001 Interview with Pat Barker “I Couldn’t Dig It”: An Interview with Arthur Miller Why Charlie Chaplin Wanted to Play Hamlet A centuries Today in Twenty How to Survive Perfume Shopping on the Upper East Side After the Love Has Gone: Reflections on the Regular Season X CEO Yaccarino responds to Israel Trumpet just became the first Bloodhound to ever win the Westminster Dog Show In a House Besieged: An Illustrated Adaptation of Lydia Davis’s Story Crying in Public 'Quordle' today: See each 'Quordle' answer and hints for October 13, 2023 Biden's American Climate Corps sees 42,000 sign Best Prime Day tablet deals still live: iPads and more Malthusian Flotsam and Unspeakable Jetsam, and Other News by Dan Piepenbring Dyson Supersonic hair dryer on sale for $100 off Reciting Sagas in the Westfjords of Iceland KitchenAid artisan mini stand mixer is on sale for $259.99 A Remembrance of Phife Dawg from His Cousin, Zinzi Clemmons
1.5814s , 10196.921875 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【eroticized synonym】,Miracle Information Network