The This Ain't Cops XXX (2010)experts have weighed in: Non-fungible tokens are dumb as hell.
The annual RSA Conference brings together some of the brightest minds in cryptography to discuss advances in the field, the year's biggest hacks, and where the cybersecurity industry is heading. This year, it just so happened to kick off with a pronounced dunk on NFTs.
The first main event of RSA 2021 was the cryptographers' panel, which followed Monday's opening keynote. At the start of the panel, Ron Rivest, a famed cryptographer who co-created RSA public-key encryption, derided non-fungible tokens as worth even less than the famed tulips of tulip mania.
At least with actual tulips, argued Rivest, "you can own them, you can posses them, you can plant them, you can enjoy them."
NFTs, Rivest observed, aren't even like pictures of tulips. They're more akin to digital tokens that point at a picture of a tulip.
"It's a bit like homeopathic medicine," said Rivest. "You dilute it, you dilute it, you dilute it, and you say, 'What's left?'"
In his mind, the answer is clearly not much.
Adi Shamir, another panelist and co-creator of RSA public-key encryption, was slightly less harsh on NFTs — but only slightly so.
"I think it's a nice way for digital artists to monetize their creations," said Shamir, before then comparing NFTs to a board game.
"I think that we should all look at it like a game of Monopoly," he told the remote audience. "Certainly it's not harmful — some people collect coins, some people collect stamps, some people collect NFTs. If they want to pay money for this, it's fine with me."
Shamir then announced plans to, at some point in the future, theoretically mint his own NFT. (Panel host Zulfikar Ramzan, who has a doctorate in computer science from MIT, clearly had been briefed on this idea beforehand and told the audience that RSA would work with Shamir to mint and sell an NFT with any proceeds going to charity.)
And while the cryptography experts may be skeptical of NFTs, it's worth noting that this conversation was even happening at RSA in the first place. In recent years, many in the cryptography community have chaffed at the term "crypto" becoming shorthand for cryptocurrency instead of cryptography. And in 2019, at the very same RSA cryptographers' panel, the assembled experts mocked the idea of "Facebook Coin."
SEE ALSO: Apple knows AirTags can be abused and is trying to get ahead of it
In some ways, Monday's panel was a continuation of this theme.
"Unfortunately in the last few years we've seen the term 'crypto' get a bit usurped by a different community of people who may expect us to talk about things like blockchain and bitcoin," Ramzan explained at the beginning of the panel discussion. "Is there any reality or any substance beyond the [NFT] hype?"
If the RSA Conference finally decides on an answer, maybe it can mint that as an NFT.
Topics Cybersecurity Cryptocurrency
This is the fattest of the extremely fat bears
What the Scientists Who Photographed the Black Hole Like to Read by Rebekah Frumkin
Redux: The One Who Outlives All the Cowards by The Paris Review
Reframing Agnes by RL Goldberg
Today's Hurdle hints and answers for April 1, 2025
What Really Killed Walt Whitman? by Caleb Johnson
Mystical, Squishy, Distinctly Unsettling by The Paris Review
More Obscene than De Sade by Lucy Sante
Bestway Hydro
There Are No Small Fascisms: An Interview with Dasa Drndic
Analyzing Graphics Card Pricing: May 2018
Redux: A Pin
The Royally Radical Life of Margaret Cavendish by Michael Robbins
Easter in Sri Lanka: Today Is Loss That Isn’t Loss by Vyshali Manivannan
Dyson V8 Plus cordless vacuum: $120 off at Amazon
There Are No Small Fascisms: An Interview with Dasa Drndic
Writers’ Fridges: Kristen Arnett by Kristen Arnett
Escaping Samuel Johnson by Peter Martin
#rateaspecies is basically Yelp reviews for zoo animals
What the Scientists Who Photographed the Black Hole Like to Read by Rebekah Frumkin
Snow White Is Tired by Alec MapesClean energy projects soared in 2016 as solar and wind got cheaperDonald Trump asked astronauts in space a question only he can answerFX's 'Shōgun' team discusses 'dream East800 wildlife species at risk from Trump's 'beautiful' border wallUNC vs. Miami basketball livestreams: Game time, streaming dealsTwo New Movies by The Paris ReviewThe White House wants your help to 'make the government tiny again'Apple’s new Earth Day videos are the least Apple thing everTikTok quietly kills hashtag view count featureFX's sports drama 'Clipped' tackles Donald Sterling's racist downfallA Night and a Day and a Night and a Day and a Night and a Day in the Dark by Lisa CarverPuppy Bowl had their own 'Taylor Swift.' See her here.The Matter of Martin by Lora KelleyNoah Hawley and FX's 'Alien' series confirmed for 2025Wordle today: The answer and hints for February 12Google's data center raises the stakes in this state's 'water wars'Kansas City Chiefs win Super Bowl in OT thriller as social media eruptsAnne Imhof’s Talent Show by Liby HaysWordle today: The answer and hints for February 11 Former Xpeng VP returns as advisor following management shakeup: report · TechNode Huawei saw a sellout launch of Mate 60 Pro model on September 3 · TechNode Tencent set to unveil its own LLM in early September · TechNode How to track your partner's location like Taylor Swift in 'Black Dog' Amazon deals of the day: Fitbit Versa 4, Kodak Mini Shot 3, and Samsung Galaxy A35. Brutal bug battle ends in a seriously surprising twist iPhone password reset attacks are real – how to protect yourself Watch out, Apple Vision Pro. An ‘Xbox How to cancel Apple TV+ Over 1 million users rush to try Baidu’s ChatGPT equivalent on the first day · TechNode NYT's The Mini crossword answers for April 20 New York Knicks vs. Philadelphia 76ers 2024 livestream: Watch NBA playoffs for free War Stories These Halloween pumpkins carved by NASA engineers are out of this world Pick from Amazon Fire and Samsung tablets. Huawei Mate 60 series may achieve sales of 20 million units · TechNode Earth will look wildly different in millions of years. Take a look. Apple confirms May 7 event: We're expecting iPads and 2 other new products Tesla cuts prices after massive Cybertruck recall Trump tells '60 Minutes' that climate change will 'change back again'
2.6377s , 8225.796875 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【This Ain't Cops XXX (2010)】,Miracle Information Network